Detail View- Square profile instead of circular

[SPerman]

I can't decide if I am doing something wrong, or if this is another SW bug. (2022 SP5.)

I am trying to create a detail view, and I want the profile to be a square instead of a circle. I am attempting to follow the instructions in this old video:


Please see the GIF below. I can create the detail view without issue. I can "edit sketch", delete the circle and replace it with a square, but after doing that, the detail view still shows a circular profile. When I click on the sketch and try and select the "Profile" radio button, it is greyed out and I cannot select it.

I know I've found a way to fight through this in the past, but I cannot remember the magic steps.

[DanPihlaja]

When you select the detail view, can you select "profile" in the property manager?

[DanPihlaja]

Nevermind. Same thing is happening to me.


That looks like a limitation. If you have ALREADY placed a circle and created the detail view, you cannot now replace the detail sketch with a square.

You have to select "profile" at the very beginning and start with a square.

[Glenn Schroeder]

I didn't look at the YouTube video, but you're trying to do it the hard way.

Sketch your shape first, then with that selected insert the Section View. At first the outline may still be a circle, but if that happens selecting "Profile" instead of "Circle" at the top of the property manager will fix it.

[SPerman]

I didn't look at the YouTube video, but you're trying to do it the hard way.

Sketch your shape first, then with that selected insert the Section View. At first the outline may still be a circle, but if that happens selecting "Profile" instead of "Circle" at the top of the property manager will fix it.

That worked.

The workaround I found was to leave the circle, but trim it. Then I could select "profile". (But I still couldn't delete the circle and replace it with a square.)

NX looks more affordable every day.

image.png (2.05 KiB) Viewed 1253 times

[jcapriotti]

Edit the profile circle, delete the sketch circle...sketch another shape then exit sketch. Then you have to change the Style to something other than "Standard" or "Broken Circle", like "with leader" which then allows you to select the profile option.

They definitely need to cleanup the UI and process, its been unchanged for like 15 years.

If I recall right, early on you HAD to sketch the profile first before the Detail View button would allow you to select it, like most functions. Then they started adding the post selection stuff....which feels awkward in some cases like this.

[SPerman]

Edit the profile circle, delete the sketch circle...sketch another shape then exit sketch. Then you have to change the Style to something other than "Standard" or "Broken Circle", like "with leader" which then allows you to select the profile option.

That's how it is supposed to work, but it wouldn't for me. Maybe you saw something I missed in the GIF?

[TTevolve]

You got to do it how Glenn said above, sketch the profile first, then select the lines and hit the detail view icon button to create the view. If you do it the way you showed in the GIF you automatically get the circle. I think you can go back and edit the circle to another shape after dropping the view on the sheet, but I never do it that way.

You also have to select full outline check box

[jcapriotti]

@SPerman Ok, I see the bug when I watched your steps more closely. When you changed the Style to "With leader" and then edited the circle sketch to a rectangle, it won't keep the change and reverts to a circle, with profile still greyed out. If you change the style to "Per Standard", then edit the sketch to a rectangle, then change the style back to "with leader", you can select Profile.

I guess my "old school" SolidWorks baggage never took me down this workflow.....I always pre-sketch the rectangle then select the Detail View command.

[Glenn Schroeder]

I forgot to mention it earlier, but the reply above from @jcapriotti reminded me. I don't know which version you're using, but beginning with SW2023 you can set the Style in the document properties (and of course in your Drawing Templates).

I've been wanting that for a long time. It might seem like a small thing, but I was getting very tired of changing the Style every stinking time I created a Detail View.

[Dwight]

I forgot to mention it earlier, but the reply above from @jcapriotti reminded me. I don't know which version you're using, but beginning with SW2023 you can set the Style in the document properties (and of course in your Drawing Templates).

I've been wanting that for a long time. It might seem like a small thing, but I was getting very tired of changing the Style every stinking time I created a Detail View.

Rats, I am one year short of SW2023. Still, good to know and something to look forward to, though it may be a few years yet.

[SPerman]

I didn't look at the YouTube video, but you're trying to do it the hard way.

Sketch your shape first, then with that selected insert the Section View. At first the outline may still be a circle, but if that happens selecting "Profile" instead of "Circle" at the top of the property manager will fix it.

I confirmed this afternoon that this methodology works as expected. Thanks again.